Hong Kong 3mt Sampan

<< First  < Prev   1   2   Next >  Last >> 
  • 20 Feb 2023 10:32
    Reply # 13103940 on 13066650

    Hello Daniele

    In a dissertation written by Hans K. Van Tilburg there is a chapter about rudders. The quality of the pdf is not great but readable, it is as I found it in the internet. The drawings you can find in the library, "Sail and Sweep" and "Les Jonques Chinoises, II) are there.


    Happy reading

    Alex


    1 file
  • 19 Feb 2023 07:58
    Reply # 13103224 on 13066650
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    Great sruff. Thanks Kevin,

  • 18 Feb 2023 11:55
    Reply # 13102529 on 13099499
    Anonymous member (Administrator)
    "...  the enormous RUDDER, not hung with pintles and gudgeons, the vessel having no stern post, but suspended to two windlasses by three large ropes made of cane and hemp: one round a windlass on the next deck, and two round a windlass on the upper deck of all, so that it can be raised or lowered according to the depth of the water in which the vessel sails. When the rudder is lowered to its full extent for going to sea, it draws about 

    Does anyone have any further detail on the traditional mounting of a Chinese rudder?

    Graeme

    [previous version of post edited to add thesis link]

    John Muir who built a precise replica of the San Francisco Bay junks which were built by Chinese builders to Chinese specs, has a fairly detailed discussion of that in the remarkable archaeological thesis he did - the transom is set back slightly from the end of the side planking and transverse planks set into that space.  Keyhole style notches are set into those planks, and the entire rudder post is then slotted down into the notches.  His thesis does not say so directly but photos of the vessel show a line running from one side of the transom down to the rudder and back to the other side, and presumably this is for lifting the rudder.  JRA has both a YouTube video and a magazine article on these California junks but for detail the thesis is the thing.  Click on this link: https://junkrigassociation.org/resources/Documents/Books/safr_Muir-John_OneOldJunk_125031_access.pdf

    Pages 112 to 114 give a very detailed description of traditional stern construction.

    and you can see a very useful stern picture illustrating these features at 2 minutes 44 seconds into the JRA video https://youtu.be/IGZjfRMztQs and again at 2’50” and 3’07”

    It all then starts to become clear, though of course there were probably more than one approach?

    Efforts to contact Mr Muir failed but maybe one of our US members visiting San Francisco could actually go visit the boat at the San Francisco national maritime historical park and take pictures of all the features?

    Last modified: 19 Feb 2023 01:40 | Anonymous
  • 16 Feb 2023 01:41
    Reply # 13099499 on 13066650
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    I will be interested to know how you mount the rudder, and to follow any research you might have done on this subject. I have read the occasional remark about lines leading from the bottom of the rudder to the bow, to hold the rudder in place – and I must say at first glance it does seem that this would be necessary. The only drawing I have seen which actually pictures it is this one – but it doesn’t show much detail. 

    This is a drawing of Free China which was done some time after she reached the USA. The "rudder bowsing line" is clearly shown here (that's not the keel profile, it's an external rope) - but no other detail is given.

    I presume that rope is led back to a windlass.

    As for hoisting, that's part of the purpose of the high poop I suppose - an attachment point for a conventional tackle, or possibly a windlass.

    As far as I know gudgeon and pintles were not used on the ancient junks, and the the stern of the hull proper is occasionally shown as an internal vee which presumably constrains the rudder stock. 

    I've always wondered how these gigantic lifting rudders were actually mounted.  

    Here is an extract from the Keying "Guide" which gives some idea:

    "...  the enormous RUDDER, not hung with pintles and gudgeons, the vessel having no stern post, but suspended to two windlasses by three large ropes made of cane and hemp: one round a windlass on the next deck, and two round a windlass on the upper deck of all, so that it can be raised or lowered according to the depth of the water in which the vessel sails. When the rudder is lowered to its full extent for going to sea, it draws about twenty-four feet, being twelve feet more than the draught of the vessel, and it is steered on this deck. It is also drawn close into the stern, into a kind of socket, by means of two immense bamboo ropes attached to the bottom of the rudder, going underneath the bottom of the vessel, and coming over the bow on the upper deck, where they are hove in taut and fastened. When let down to its greatest depth, it requires, occasionally, the strength of fifteen men to move the large tiller, and even then with the aid of a luff tackle purchase and the best patent blocks. Without this aid it would require thirty men. On one occasion, when the junk was running before a fresh gale, attended with hail squalls, a tiller rope of nine inches was snapped in two like a piece of thread. The rudder is now hoisted up and a small tiller shipped in it on the upper deck. It is made of iron-wood and teak, bound with iron, its weight is from seven and a half to eight tons, and it is perforated with rhomboidal holes. ..."


    The scores of lines drawings and sail plans in China Offshore Fishing Atlas shows a huge variety of these large rudders, many of them with stocks, and some clearly with pintles - but these were all records of vessels still in existence in the 1950s, by which time Chinese naval architecture was becoming hybridised with that of the West.

    Does anyone have any further detail on the traditional mounting of a Chinese rudder?

    Last modified: 16 Feb 2023 02:22 | Anonymous member (Administrator)
  • 29 Jan 2023 18:35
    Reply # 13077270 on 13066650
    Deleted user

    Hello,

    I had some time to design and I added more details to the boat.

    A rudder, slightly raked. I am still thinking about a proper way to hoist it, I will have to use ropes, as Chinese did.

    I added also a rig, wich is the Halibout Extended Rig, that I found in the Junket thread (not my design).

    I did not calculate the CE yet, and I think I will have to step the mast a bit back, of may be to increase a bit the depth of the keel. We will see.

    Comments and Opinions welcome.

    2 files
  • 22 Jan 2023 11:36
    Reply # 13067598 on 13067115
    Deleted user
    Anonymous wrote:

    DVV wrote:

    What do you think? Opinions and questions are welcome.

    I love the lines. No one seems to make sheer lines like that anymore. I am not sure if that means it is just so much easier (and less expensive) to make straight sheer hulls in a factory, or if straight sheers are easier to sail and more sea kindly. It is obvious to me that a hull made with all uniform width planks will tend toward high ends. I would guess straight decks would be easier to walk on too (though that is of no concern in this case). What is the length? It looks like it should be 4 or 5 meters going by the motor size. 3 would be a bit short for a pointy end I think.

    I think the shape of the sheer depends from many thing, and tradition has a large part in this. Chinese vessels have high bow and sterns, this being a traditional style sampan replicates those features.

    In theory a blunt shaped bow high would be slightly easier to build, but I dont think the difference would be that much.

    This is supposed to be 3mt. It is to be used in restricted areas with and there is a limitation in dimensions. The original one should be around the same size.

  • 21 Jan 2023 20:00
    Reply # 13067115 on 13066650

    DVV wrote:

    What do you think? Opinions and questions are welcome.

    I love the lines. No one seems to make sheer lines like that anymore. I am not sure if that means it is just so much easier (and less expensive) to make straight sheer hulls in a factory, or if straight sheers are easier to sail and more sea kindly. It is obvious to me that a hull made with all uniform width planks will tend toward high ends. I would guess straight decks would be easier to walk on too (though that is of no concern in this case). What is the length? It looks like it should be 4 or 5 meters going by the motor size. 3 would be a bit short for a pointy end I think.
  • 21 Jan 2023 10:26
    Message # 13066650
    Deleted user

    Hello.

    I'm trying to develop a reproduction of a 3mt Sampan of Hong Kong.

    This is a traditional local type. Originally used with sails, now motoring.

    I attach some pic of my design and of the original boat.

    I kept all the peculiar features of these kind of vessel: large overhangs, sampan bow, max beam quite aft, bow and transom in the water. The large opening in the transom is due to the use of a motor, but I would like to add a deep rudder (hopefully rising) and a junk rig of around 7 square meters (Halibut rig?)

    What do you think? Opinions and questions are welcome.

    DVV


    6 files
<< First  < Prev   1   2   Next >  Last >> 
       " ...there is nothing - absolutely nothing - half so much worth doing as simply messing about in junk-rigged boats" 
                                                               - the Chinese Water Rat

                                                              Site contents © the Junk Rig Association and/or individual authors

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software