This post turned out pretty long, skip to the bottom to see the pictures of the new sailplan. If you're interested in the details of how I came to it, or have time to comment/criticize my design that would be appreciated.
It has been a bit of a journey, but I'm finally ready to start sewing sails for Leeway. We started refitting her because we thought she'd make a good Junk Rig platform for us, but had some shortcomings. In the end we completely gutted her, and re-ballasted the boat and moved the fore-mast. As refits do, things have taken a while but we're finally ready to sew our Junk Sails, which was the idea that started this whole project. Details of Leeway are on page 1 of the thread, but basically she's a Jay Benford Brigantine (40') that weighs about 28 000lb in cruising trim. Her original sail area was 940 sqft (87m2). I originally drew sails close to Arne's, along with working through PJR. That was early in the refit and what allowed me to get on with moving the fore-mast and then building the rest of the boat interior.
In the end, given Leeways tall masts, that are pretty skinny at the top (4", 102mm), I think I'd prefer shorter/lighter yards. At bottom below are figures of my preferred current sailplan along with it superimposed with the older 70o yard sailplan I drew. I suspect (hope) either would work, but the shorter lower angle yards check more boxes for me.
The forums on the JRA were invaluable, although sometimes dizzying, source of information beyond what PJR provides. Some of the design features of the sailplan include:
-shorter low-angle yards for less weight aloft (yard goes from 12.5kg down to 8.5kg) inspired by David Tyler's Weaverbird
-like Arne and PJR, all the lower panels are the same to simplify construction
-as per Arne and David Tyler, battens are at 10o as a replacement for the batten angle calculations for flat panel sails PJR recommends
-Boom has 4% removed as per Arne's instructions to help avoid sheet tangles
-Second batten from the top slightly longer than sail to help avoid sheet tangles
-foremast is raked forward 4o to help sail behave when running downwind, thanks to recommendation by Annie Hill
-luff of foresail is parallel to the raked mast. The plan is to use short batten parrels with both ends attached to the luff a' la Paul Fay to control the fore-aft position of the battens. Given the strong taper of our mast this should help encourage positive batten stagger when reefing.
-mainsail is canted 2.5o on the mast. Mostly, this allows a bit better clearance with the fore-sail sheets. I also like the look given the raked fore-sail. It also helps the very tight Dmin for sheeting the main. This probably also gives a bit of anti-twist to the main (more balance higher up), which is good given the steep sheeting angles make it harder to control the top of the sail.
-Both sails have split lower and upper sheeting. A single sheet system can make it hard to control twist in the top of a high aspect ratio sail (David Tyler) and Arne has used split upper and lower sheets on the schooner Samson successfully. I'd prefer a single sheet per sail, but we'll start with upper and lower.
-Comparing the 45o yard to the 70o yard, you end up with a bit more area in your "storm canvas" as the area of the top two panels increases from 11m2 with the 70o yard to 13m2 with the 40o yard.
The finished sailplan is 97.8m2 (1050ft2), compared to 99m2 (1062ft2) of the 70o yard or the 87m2 (940ft2) she started with as a staysail schooner.
Thanks to everyone, including those I've forgotten to mention whose contributed to improving my understanding. I think I'm now at the point where I have begun to know what I don't know :-)