52sqm : V69 or V92 thread?

  • 28 May 2017 20:50
    Reply # 4857063 on 4832953
    Many many thanks Annie, David and Arne,

    This feels like the kind of advice that will save us hours of frustration and toil. Time is running horribly short, so your help is much appreciated!

    That thing of needles looking and feeling quite sharp is just the same with my Wood-Mizer bandsaw. The blunt blades can still be quite prickly, but they don't cut... We will keep a close eye on our needles! It turns out we have a box of six. Big box will be on order this week. Sailmaking starts a week tomorrow.

    Arne, glad you reckon narrow Dyneema will be OK. Yes, easier going than the seatbelt stuff.

    Annie, there are no limits to your talents - clothes-making as well as everything else. Amanda started making clothes again quite recently. You'll know what I mean if I tell you she has just made something very similar to the hooded Swanndris that I've been wearing for work for about 20 years! These things have got quite expensive recently.

    Cheers again,

    Pol

  • 27 May 2017 10:00
    Reply # 4855298 on 4832953
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    Pol,

    here are two tricks I had to learn the hard way when sewing the biggest sails. When sewing in ordinary cloth, cotton and stuff like that, I had not met them:

    ·         Make sure the z-screw holding the needle is set firmly. The needle not only needs to punch its way through all the layers of cloth and webbing  -  it also has to be pulled back out again. I did the error of not tightening the screw hard enough. What happened then was that the needle sometimes slipped in the socket, just a millimetre or two . This meant that the tip now was a little lower, so next time it was on its way down, it hit metal. This of course blunted the tip rapidly. I broke a couple of needles because of this when sewing ED’s white sail in 2012, until I learned to identify the ticking noise. Nowadays I keep a little plier ready when changing needle to add just a bit extra torque on the z-screw (without  breaking it...).

    ·         Sewing all these layers with the thick needle and thread has forced me to use high thread tension (over-thread) to balance out the under-thread tension, even if this is set light. When lifting the foot at the end of a seam, I bent a few needles because I pulled the cloth towards me to cut off the thread. I have now taught myself to pull the cloth away from me, which saves the needle.

    The Dyneema webbing sounds like a good idea. My guess is that the sewing machine will like it better than the 2” seatbelt webbing I use.

    Good luck!

    Arne


  • 27 May 2017 08:26
    Reply # 4855178 on 4832953

    Yup, if you start to miss stitches, take the needle out and look at the point under a bright light. If light reflects back from the point, it's too blunt.

    You can also expect to bend a few, as you drag the heavy cloth along, and if you attempt to punch through too many thicknesses. A box of 100 needles is a good investment.

    The other thing to do when you get bad stitches - oil the bobbin race.

  • 27 May 2017 00:47
    Reply # 4854901 on 4854644
    POL BERGIUS wrote:Fortunately the sewing machine came with a 110 needle.
    The burgundy will look sharp!  But talking of sharp, your needles need to be very sharp in order to sew properly.  Because they feel that way when you stick one in your finger, it's hard to believe that they have gone blunt, but they do. 

    If everything has been going fine and you suddenly have problems: change the needle.  You may need as many as half a dozen on your big sail.  Also ensure that the machine is completely dust free - It's amazing how a bit of dust can completely upset the mechanism.  They are wonderful creations, but need love and care like all of us.

    BTW, I also make clothes as well as sails and I guess that is why I see no reason to use an excessively heavy thread.  But if it works for you, why not?


  • 26 May 2017 21:24
    Reply # 4854644 on 4832953

    Hi there Arne and David,

    Thank you both very much for your comments. My initial thought was to go with the heavier V92, and although I really see where Annie is coming from - being that there are much lower stresses on the cloth and seams in a junk sail - nonetheless I'm thinking it does make sense to go for higher volume in the thread itself. I'm glad of David's comment about coloured thread, as it reinforced my view that a brown or dark red thread might look good with a cream sail so we ordered some "burgundy" V92 from PT Winchester.

    Fortunately the sewing machine came with a 110 needle.

    Thanks Arne for the two links to the making of ED's sail. Sewing in horizontal panel seams seems to be a logical method, probably quicker to do and offering a bit more protection from chafe. Our "half lenses", as you put it, will be a bit wider than on ED's sail I think. Amanda has made a few scaled down mock-up templates, and has marked out two or three panels on some ancient calico that we had knocking about, so sail making has started! We are still waiting for the village hall to get back to us on how much they want for us to use the floor...

    Gross extravagance here: I couldn't find non-stretch white or cream webbing apart from one (but the seller could not vouch for its non-stretch qualities) so I ordered Dyneema which is only 25mm wide. Now that I have it it does look a bit mean, but will it be OK? Of course stretch is not going to be a problem, but will the lighter webbing - compared with the weight of 40 or 50mm stuff, be sufficient stiffness in the luff/leech?

    Apologies that my text seems to be disappearing off the edges of this post.

    Thanks again,

    Pol.





  • 19 May 2017 15:17
    Reply # 4842019 on 4832953

    Pol,

    I used V69 on the same cloth as you have,  but only because I had some and because the sail is small. If I were buying a new spool of thread, I'd be going for V92.

    As for the colour, I still think it's worth buying black and using it for everything. Not only because of UV, but because you can easily spot broken stitches that need attention. With a cream sail, tan thread is an attractive option, visually.

  • 17 May 2017 10:10
    Reply # 4837685 on 4832953
    Anonymous member (Administrator)

    Funny, that.

    In my head thick thread is good and thicker is better. Not that it is needed for strength the first year, but having some reserve strength is to me a good thing when the sun has worked on the sail for a few years. I have had enough sails where the seams rotted away (ordinary sails) while the cloth still looked ok.

    The last three sails I have made, for Edmond Dantes (48sqm), Frøken Sørensen (20) and Ingeborg (35), were all sewed up with V92 thread (110 needle).

    The thread is at the upper end of what my domestic Pfaff 360 will take, but it works by keeping it well lubricated. I often drip one single drop of oil on the full underthread bobbin.

    David Tyler mentioned that the vertical seams, when laying the panels vertically, are vulnerable to chafe from the lazyjacks. I suggest you simply make the sails with the cloth laying along the battens. If you look up how the sail of Edmond Dantes was made, here and here you can see how we added a bit cloth to make the panels wide enough to produce each batten panel. I guess it is better to add a bit cloth both along the upper and lower edge on your bigger sail. These seams should stay well outside “chafe’s way” with respect to the topping lift.

    I suggest you buy a little bobbin of V92 thread and do a bit test-sewing with is. If your sewing machine is reluctant to handle it, then go for V69.

    Anyway, good luck!

    Arne

     

  • 16 May 2017 20:44
    Reply # 4836873 on 4832953

    Thank you very much for your advice, Annie, and for your time! It is fantastic to see Siblim on her keel. We'll go for V69. A lighter thread must be easier to use. As you point out, the sail cloth is not under the kind of loads that others are. We have a heavy recon. Janome machine which we found on ebay for £200 at sewing4everyone. We bought it as we seem to have a growing number of uses for such a thing. I'll be putting something  about your namesake's conversion on my profile sometime soon.

    Thanks again, Pol.


  • 16 May 2017 10:21
    Reply # 4835781 on 4832953

    It depends a bit on your sewing machine, Pol.  Most domestic machines won't handle anything more than V69.  However, all your thread really needs to do is hold the material together - you don't get the panel loading on a junk sail that you get with gaff or pointy rig.  It's a big sail, yes, but it's not particularly heavy canvas, I suppose.  I'd be inclined to go for the V69 unless you have an industrial sewing machine.  If you go for 92, you will need BIG needles to go with it.

    It used to be the case that the darker threads lasted longer, but I'm not sure if that's still true.  And even with climate change, I doubt that UV degradation is going to be a big deal in Scotland.  Besides, it's quite easy to hand stitch an old seam where the thread has rotted out - use a domestic (round) sewing needle and make sure you go through the old needle holes. 

  • 14 May 2017 21:06
    Message # 4832953
    Hi All,

    At long last we are underway with the conversion of our gaffer ANNIE. I'm doing a few days a week on the boat on mast step and partners etc, while at home we look apprehensively at  the enormous roll of cloth from English Seadogs / Tough Textiles (in Portland, Dorset). It is 7.2oz "soft dacron" which feels very much like Clipper Canvas, but at a fraction of the cost of that fine stuff. 

    A while back I made a note that David Tyler suggests V69 thread on the vertical panel seams which are subject to chafe from lazyjacks, because it beds in better than V92.. At 52-55sqm is that OK for a sail of this size (from Arne's A/R 1.9-2.0 plan), and can we use it throughout the sail, or should we use V92 for the rest? I've also seen mentioned the better UV resistance of black thread over white. ANNIE's sail is cream, so white thread seems right, but (in the W of Scotland) is that UV thing really a consideration?!

    Thanks a lot,

    Pol.


       " ...there is nothing - absolutely nothing - half so much worth doing as simply messing about in junk-rigged boats" 
                                                               - the Chinese Water Rat

                                                              Site contents © the Junk Rig Association and/or individual authors

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software