Alan,
I think the improvement of La Chica could have two reasons. Her draught was increased, and is (if my drawings are up to date) around 163cm, with the new rudder almost as deep.
Paul also reported about a bad weather helm with the old rudder. Curing that with the better rudder (now in ‘free’ water flow well aft of the hull), no doubt removed a serious brake.
If I look at the right hull plan in Annie Hill’s book, then the keel of Zebedee is only 3’6” (1.06m). This alone should give you quite a handicap to windward. I see no reason for doing fixes to the rudder of Z. unless she has a bad weather helm when fully close-hauled. Has she?.
Just curious.
Arne