Top Hat 25: How long should my mast be?

  • 17 Jan 2021 09:29
    Reply # 9870275 on 9859908

    The mast position in the drawing Matt posted was just a a guess. The one I show here is my 2nd attempt and is based on some rough calculations I made using the methods suggested in PJR. I should point out though the scale of the sail is slightly different to the scale of the boat. it was more to give myself an idea of how it would look. I have since scaled an image of the Tophat but I haven't printed it yet. Life getting in the way and all that.


    1 file
    Last modified: 17 Jan 2021 09:35 | Anonymous member
  • 17 Jan 2021 00:06
    Reply # 9869902 on 9868506
    Howard Wilkinson wrote:

     At the risk of showing my ignorance again.....    The drawing of Gary's sail plan looks far out of balance to my eye with the C of E far forward of the CLR.   That's a lot of keel back there.   I'd be interested in hearing the explanation for this.


                                                          H.W.

    I'm not that smart, myself, Howard, when it comes to engineering, sort of a monkey see, monkey do sort of a guy.  Given that the Top Hat is a production boat designed with a bermudian rig, the simplest thing, in my opinion, is to place the JR CE in the same place as it is on the bermudian rig, and trust the original designer (famous Englishman, John Illingworth) knew what he was doing.  I did the same thing on Arion and it worked just fine.  There have been some suggestions the JR CE should be a bit further fwd than the bermudian version, but there are so many variables, including the beam and displacement of the hull, that I think it safest to keep the CE the same.  On Blue Moon, the JR CE is a little aft of the bermudian rig CE, even though Paul Thompson designed a rig for me with as much balance forward of the mast as possible (I was stuck with an existing mast, designed for a junkette rig, which has a jib).  That is why I suggest the mast a little further forward, and Matt Waite's estimate of 300mm seems right to me.
  • 16 Jan 2021 15:41
    Reply # 9868506 on 9859908
    Deleted user
    Anonymous wrote:

    Mast length for a Top Hat 25

    Member Gary Pick drew up this (below) sail plan for a Toppie.

    He was looking at a timber mast 220mm at the partners tapering to 100mm at the top, 9 metres long, which weighs in at 87kg (about 3.6% of the weight of a Toppie - Arne reckons 3% is ideal). Gary's already made it.

    I thinking of going with the same, but I'm unsure about the length.

    I've decided to go with a timber, keel-stepped mast right in front of the cabintop. That would give the mast 1.2m of bury, from the partners to the keel.

    The sail, when it's made, will need to have a shorter lead to compensate - somewhat like Speedwell's (see pic), though not as far forward.

    Graham Cox wrote of his experience with his JR Toppie Blue Moon: "The ideal place for a proper junk rig is just fwd of the cabin top, on the foredeck. Blue Moon has more lead in the sail design, 22-25%, to compensate, but it is not ideal. About 300-450mm further forward would be better. If you placed the mast right up against the fwd end of the cabin, on the foredeck, I think the position would be perfect for your (Gary Pick's) sail."

    Graham also reckons 11m would be a good mast length Toppie.

    Step 1 in my junk conversion, and the most difficult step for me, is getting the mast.

    Time, space and skills mean I'm looking at having a mast made for me. I'm looking at a birdsmouth timber mast, 220mm at the partners tapering to 100mm at the top. Just like Gary Pick's. The only question is the length. I reckon i can manage fabricating partners and step, and bracing the underside of the foredeck, but a mast is beyond me.

    So, how long should it be?

    In my cruising grounds (Victoria, Australia) often as not the wind is 'fresh' - often too fresh. Given Toppie's reputation as initially tender, I think I'd rather err on the side of shorter, and keep weight aloft to a minimum.

    Cheers,

    Matt

     At the risk of showing my ignorance again.....    The drawing of Gary's sail plan looks far out of balance to my eye with the C of E far forward of the CLR.   That's a lot of keel back there.   I'd be interested in hearing the explanation for this.


                                                          H.W.

  • 16 Jan 2021 06:36
    Reply # 9867760 on 9859908
    Deleted user

    Thanks for that Graham, very thorough and informative, as always.

    My proposed mast position is probably only 300mm or so further forward than yours.

    It'd be interesting to know the mast height of Speedwell (I've emailed Shirley). I know her rig is low aspect, but the info would still be interesting.

  • 16 Jan 2021 01:18
    Reply # 9865027 on 9859908

    My mast is 8.3m above the cabin top fwd, so about 8.5m above the foredeck.  Spar length is 4m with a 6-panel sail giving 23 sq m.  It is more than enough when the wind is 12 knots or more.  But if I ever replaced the mast, I would make it 1m higher and add an additional panel to the foot of the sail, giving 27 sq m, which is close to the bermudian sail area.  Reefing is easy!  And  the weight of the rig is in the sail, not the mast, so the centre of gravity of the rig comes down as you reef.  The top of the tapered mast, without standing rigging, is both light and has minimal windage. You could get more than 23 sq m of sail area by going for a lower aspect sail, like Speedwell, but I am not sure if you will have enough drift for the sheet. (Though Speedwell, at 25ft also, apparently does.)  When my sail is furled, there is only about 300 mm between the lower sisterblocks on the sheetlets and the deck blocks.  Of course, if the mast is further forward, there will be more room aft, allowing slightly longer spars.

    Here is a photo of Blue Moon taken recently motor-sailing down Moreton Bay in light airs.  Click on the photo for full sized image.  I have the tack of the sail pulled well aft here.


    Last modified: 16 Jan 2021 01:25 | Anonymous member
  • 14 Jan 2021 23:28
    Message # 9859908
    Deleted user

    Mast length for a Top Hat 25

    Member Gary Pick drew up this (below) sail plan for a Toppie.

    He was looking at a timber mast 220mm at the partners tapering to 100mm at the top, 9 metres long, which weighs in at 87kg (about 3.6% of the weight of a Toppie - Arne reckons 3% is ideal). Gary's already made it.

    I thinking of going with the same, but I'm unsure about the length.

    I've decided to go with a timber, keel-stepped mast right in front of the cabintop. That would give the mast 1.2m of bury, from the partners to the keel.

    The sail, when it's made, will need to have a shorter lead to compensate - somewhat like Speedwell's (see pic), though not as far forward.

    Graham Cox wrote of his experience with his JR Toppie Blue Moon: "The ideal place for a proper junk rig is just fwd of the cabin top, on the foredeck. Blue Moon has more lead in the sail design, 22-25%, to compensate, but it is not ideal. About 300-450mm further forward would be better. If you placed the mast right up against the fwd end of the cabin, on the foredeck, I think the position would be perfect for your (Gary Pick's) sail."

    Graham also reckons 11m would be a good mast length Toppie.

    Step 1 in my junk conversion, and the most difficult step for me, is getting the mast.

    Time, space and skills mean I'm looking at having a mast made for me. I'm looking at a birdsmouth timber mast, 220mm at the partners tapering to 100mm at the top. Just like Gary Pick's. The only question is the length. I reckon i can manage fabricating partners and step, and bracing the underside of the foredeck, but a mast is beyond me.

    So, how long should it be?

    In my cruising grounds (Victoria, Australia) often as not the wind is 'fresh' - often too fresh. Given Toppie's reputation as initially tender, I think I'd rather err on the side of shorter, and keep weight aloft to a minimum.

    Cheers,

    Matt

    4 files
       " ...there is nothing - absolutely nothing - half so much worth doing as simply messing about in junk-rigged boats" 
                                                               - the Chinese Water Rat

                                                              Site contents © the Junk Rig Association and/or individual authors

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software