David wrote:
Well Jim, all us 'old diesel heads' will await with interest for the outcome of your conversion. A good diesel installation can be relied on when the going gets tough. But they come with complications, so if electric motor can perform the same job consistently and reliably it can only be a good thing. I remember being very surprised at the minuscule dimensions of the electric motor in mehitabel so certainly a clean tidy installation.
... until you add in six x 8V or eight x 6V golf cart batteries and a big controller.
I did look at the possibility of an electric outboard motor on the little catamaran I am building, but I do not think I can provide the battery charging capabilities on such a small yacht, so it looks like a small 4 stroke petrol outboard is the only practical solution. Not to mention the fact that a good electric outboard is many times the cost of a petrol outboard.
Oh, how I wish that electric propulsion was a sensible proposition for Weaverbird - I will never be a 'petrolhead'! I would never want to go the hybrid route, building in the problems of an ICE, as well as the costs and complexity of an inboard electric installation, but with sun and wind power in place of fossil fuel, I could be persuaded about a small outboard. Financially, it never will be sensible, but practically, the numbers are beginning to make sense.
Nestaway Boats is a good place to compare four direct equivalents: Suzuki and Lehr 2.5HP petrol/gas, Epropulsion Spirit and Torqeedo 1103 1KW electric.
Photonic Universe is a good place to look at solar panels, wind turbines and controllers.
In practical terms, it would appear that an Epropulsion Spirit would fit into the well of my Hunter Duette, and more importantly, could be fairly easily lifted out of the well and stored, when I'm at anchor or on a long passage, which the current Tohatsu 6 can't.
A 250 watt solar panel could be fitted as a kind of bimini, where a full width sprayhood normally goes over the companionway. With a 30A MPPT controller to make the most of this and my existing 100 watt panel, I think I could get the equivalent in performance of a 2.5HP petrol or propane outboard, with adequate recharging, at a "trifling" 3.3 times the cost. I found a Suzuki 2.5 too tricky to manoeuvre with, having only a F-N shift low down on the wrong side. An electric drive ought to be easier to work with, when coming alongside.
Anyone looking for a secondhand Tohatsu 6 Sailpro?!