All well, then.
I admit that I tend to pile on as much sail as possible, as long as I can hoist and sheet it. When rigging Johanna, back in 2002, I probably touched my limits: To hoist her 48sqm sail, I had to use the winch for the last two panels. Later I fitted an electric winch handle (which I have kept). After first having sailed her for two summers with the BR, I knew her rudder was very powerful, so I gambled and gave her 5.8m long battens (Chord=5.71m), which meant that the sail’s chord was 84% the length of the waterline. Johanna still behaved quite well, and could carry the same sail area, or one panel more, downwind, compared to when close-hauled.
Recently, when I designed the rig for my IF, Ingeborg, my hearth wanted a 40sqm sail, but my head vetoed against it, so I landed on 35sqm. The idea is to be able to hoist sail without needing a halyard winch. With the battens being 4.9m, the chord/wll=80%, so I hope Ingeborg will steer well enough, downwind.
When I spotted David’s sailplan for Weaverbird, I noticed that she appeared to have a very good rudder, and that was my reason for thinking she could carry more sail without needing a longer mast. I guess my attitude is... there is no substitute for square-meters, downwind... and I am too one-eyed to think that other people may see it differently...
Anyway, good luck with your project, David!
Arne.