EDITED
I do own that I made the statement “8' is too small to be worth putting a junk rig on” which was a value judgement I should not have made in such blunt terms. I apologise for that, because I do sincerely support and appreciate the efforts of the committee and did not mean that statement to be as negative as it sounds.
Of course you can put a junk rig on an 8’ dinghy, as we know it has been done. In fact, I am eagerly looking forward to seeing Annie’s junk-rigged tender when the competition eventually yields a winner – in which case I might be very tempted to have a go at making one too.
(By the way, evidently the committee has thought about this and is maybe on the right track, because nowhere in the criteria is there any requirement for the JRA sailing tender to be junk rigged – merely that it should be easily reefed. Annie and I both overlooked that small point, and it makes a bit of a difference).
The sponsored JRA dinghy design really ought to be junk rigged, despite the small size of the boat and the (in my opinion) impracticality of it. Annie is absolutely right in her vision of fun and frivolity arising from a few little junks buzzing around the anchorage at a junket. That, surely, must be the main goal and point of the exercise, and is surely more fun than sitting around at anchor all day, which is what I have observed most people doing at the “tall ships” I have attended in the last three years.
Therein lies the real challenge. There are plenty of simple-to-build plywood tender designs which are known to be (more or less) suitable. But no-one has yet designed a junk rig especially suitable for an 8’ dinghy. That would be a worthwhile challenge.
The real challenge is not to design the hull, but to make a variation of the junk rig which can be carried as a bundle in one hand, spar lengths stowable, able to be set up or struck in a jiffy (or at least just a minute or two) and able to deploy while actually on the water. Then we will have a tiny, practical junk-rigged tender which will be reefable and really safe to sail away in, turn envious eyes – and actually get used.
Can it be done? Yes, I think maybe it can.
I’m in support of the JRA Tender competition - but I am still going to pursue the junket boat idea.
You can’t have too many boats…. can you?
Edit: I've just seen Arne's latest post which popped up while writing this.
Well done, I love the 5-plank configuration. Handsome and jaunty Halibut is crying out for a little centreboard and rudder, and a bit better sail plan. Back to the drawing board Arne, for 2-minute-deployable Johanna rig!
When sailing a little dinghy you have to shift your bum around a bit - sometimes from the bottom of the boat (which is the best place) to a thwart. When you get old like me, low thwarts are the best. Its a little beauty Arne.
So far, David has produced the simplest-to-build hull shape and best arrangement of buoyancy, moveable thwart, and off-centre board (one's enough I reckon) and the best looking rig, but presumably the judging committee will need to see some more details, ie the running rigging and how quickly it can be deployed.