James Pike wrote:
Invitation to speculate? I hate to hijack the thread. I think the bilge keel one is easier than the junk sail. Bilge keel boats have enormous practicality around the UK because of the size of the tides people have to contend with. People have their boats regularly - every day - 'dry out'. That doesn't seem to happen in many places in NA certainly not enough to effect production design. I think there is also a structural cost to providing that kind of "hold up the boat with angled supports" built right into the hull.
Even more guessing going on here. The junk rig motivation is I think 70% aesthetics and 30% misplaced perceived need for pointing ability. A Bermudian rig just looks simpler and more advanced. People in the US and Canada are largely sailing in protected waterways for enjoyment and don't have a deep connection to the sea. In the UK there aren't large protected areas of ocean/lake and the ocean is everywhere. I think that forces a more practical mindful approach to sea going equipment. Anything that keeps an ocean going sailor from going forward in rough weather is incredibly valuable.
Hi James,
Those of us in New England keep hoping to see more bilge keel boats available here – from Cape Cod and north, our tides range from 10 to 18 feet, with the highest ones as you go further along the Maine coast toward Canada. it's a puzzle why bilge keels have not caught on more.
As for junk rig sailors in the USA, there are more of us than you would think! We are in the process of organizing a junket for this September, in Maine, and have had good responses by e-mail. I would take issue, on the subject of "deep connection to the sea!" There are long traditions on all the US coasts, including working sail, from before engines took over. But it's very true that you have to travel a VERY long way between coasts! I have envied the UK, for the coast being so nearby everywhere, and the way that influences how the inhabitants relate to the sea. In the US and Canada, it's a more select group, those of us who are near enough to feel it with so much connection.