Quicker than a winch, stronger than hands-only.
That trip was the first test of my Mk III halyard hauler. The Mk I from last spring was good for a while, but the shaft at the pawl soon became rickety. The Mk II was made stouter. However, I still found it to be a challenge to get the pawls just right: Too flat angle and the line would slip, too steep angle and it would jam. In the end, I made it work well, but I would not dare to recommend it. This Mk III version, with a real camcleat on it, appears to be the one I will recommend. I will use it a bit more first (with and without the bungee in front), and then produce a little write-up about it (sigh...). This model fits within a sheet of paper, so the drawing can simply be printed out and be used as a pattern.
My manual hoisting of Ingeborg’s 35sqm/40kg sail goes about like this:
· The first three panels goes up quickly, hauling hand over hand, while standing up.
· The next panel may be hauled up conventionally, still standing up.
· The three last panels goes up, using the halyard hauler. The halyard has then been wound one round around the sb. genoa winch and I sit on the opposite bench and ‘row’ the sail up with the hauler.
Edit 20190722: I find it easier now to just pass the halyard 'around the corner' of the winch, not needing to take a turn around it. My 5-part halyard is easy to hold with one hand while pushing the hauler back between each pull.
(...thanks to the parachute drogue, I don't need to hurry…)
I find the hauler to be at its best when the forces needed are just a bit higher than my hands will like, but still not so high that I need to use a winch.
In short, the hauler is quicker than the winch and stronger than my hands.
Arne