Anonymous wrote:
The conclusion I have reached once again is that where on board storage space is limited, a reasonable carrying capacity is needed, dinghy light enough to lift on board, and reasonable rowing capability is needed, that an inflatable dinghy with an inflatable air floor, and inflatable keel is regrettably the best solution. But forget about the aluminium and plastic paddles they supply with these dinghies. I have always replaced these with some decent wooden oars.
David thanks for this. You make me revisit the inflatable solution again.
I would guess Zebedee and Badger used the Tortoise due to reliability, economy and functionality for long range remote cruising.
My initial needs are different as I won't be so remote and have a base for now. While inflatable is more expensive and fragile, it is easy to launch solo without damaging the yacht, can't sink if swamped (picture remote location/ 2 people/ load of stores), can be deflated for transport or storage in yacht and at a pinch is a short term survival craft.
The inflatable would struggle to carry a kedge or second bower out though a model with a solid transom would manage this better.
Thanks for poking my brain.
David.