Is the halyard block the Achilles’ heel of the junk rig?
Is the top halyard block the riskiest part of a junk rig? Is it also the cause of most difficulty in what is otherwise a super-easy rig?
Is there a solution?
Let me just start this by saying that I am just a day sailor, mostly. I have been sailing for about six years, but this consists of short sails close to home, not very far, mostly (although I did a longer cruise this year with Iain Blair). So even after a few years, I don’t feel I have the in-depth experience and technical knowledge to answer the questions I have just asked. But maybe just about enough to start asking some of the right questions?
The junk rig has never put me in a dangerous situation. But three times now, it has put me in a situation which would have been dangerous in stronger winds and/or bigger seas. All three times it was a question of the sail getting stuck at the top of the mast. Easy reefing doesn’t happen if you let go of the halyard but the sail remains in the same place.
The first time this happened, I grabbed the leech as high up as I could and yanked and jerked, and eventually the sail dropped. The second time, this strategy did not work until combined with a bit of gybing back and forth, when eventually the bind at the top loosened and the sail started to descend.
The last time, I was trying out a different sail on Wave Rover, my current boat. I raised the sail as far as I could but then could not get it to drop. Eventually I enlisted the help of marina staff. I took the boat around to the raised boat-lift dock, where they could stand several metres above deck level (thankfully it was low tide) and they could use a boat hook to reach the yard and halyard blocks and pull from there. The next step would have been to cut the halyard at the top of the mast.
Mauro Pau’s article in the latest JRA magazine brought these incidents back to mind. He was not in the marina but at sea, and in his case the solution was to climb up the mast and quite literally bounce on the battens until the jam freed itself. I was frightened just reading it. And I’m a quite large 66-year-old chap on a light boat. Climbing the mast just isn’t going to be practical for me.
With a three- or four-part arrangement and side-by-side blocks as I have, the lines do not run exactly straight. At some point the line has to run from the starboard side of one block to the port side of another, or vice versa. When the sail is lowered, this is a minuscule degree of variation — a few centimetres over maybe six or more metres. But at the top, it’s proportionately much more pronounced — the same few centimetres over a much shorter distance of, on my mast and just a rough guess, less than half a metre. This means friction, or the potential for it at least, and friction is the enemy of easy hauling and easy reefing.
Add in any unintended twist at all, and there is a serious risk that one of the strands of the halyard under tension will jam against another and create that binding effect that I and Mauro have experienced.
A lesser problem, but still important, is that using a four-part or three-part system makes it much easier to haul up the sail, but not three or four times easier. Because each turn of a block adds to the friction in the system. I was lucky enough to sail on a member’s Kingfisher 20 a couple of years ago and it was a great boat, but hard enough to raise sail. Not difficult, but harder than I expected for the size of boat.
So here’s my question: is there a way to reduce the risk of halyard binding, to coin a phrase, and also to reduce the friction that makes hauling the sail a bit of an effort?
Better block discipline
I solved the problem on my boat by being much more careful about eliminating twist from the halyard system. I know there are different views on this, but I have limited the amount of possible twist in the halyard system by removing the possibility that the halyard blocks can rotate. This can be done by using blocks that don’t rotate, or in my case by limiting their potential rotation with cable ties.
The reason for the cable ties instead of just a fixed block is that the block needs some freedom to align with its load, but I don’t want it to rotate and twist the line. But cable ties also have issues and limitations and need to be checked regularly.
And I check each time I go out that the halyard is not twisted.
In-line blocks
And I noticed in a recent forum post that David Tyler recommended using in-line blocks, rather than side-by-side blocks in the halyard system. [edit - David confirms he did not,
so my misunderstanding, sorry]. So simple, I’m wondering why I never thought of it. In my own case, I don’t have much space at the top of the mast, so maybe I don’t have the luxury of using the small amount of extra space that they take up, but surely worth a try? They would presumably also need to be prevented from rotating, but must eliminate the crossover point where the halyard must move from one side to another.
I wonder, do they also reduce hauling friction? No side-to-side movement should help, but in those in-line blocks one of the sheaves is necessarily smaller, with a tighter turning curve than another. So what is the friction effect of this?
As I write this, it occurs to me that I should not skimp on the blocks that I use. Fortunately, mine are quite good, but this would be one area where going cheap would be a risk rather than a saving.
Taller masts
For most of us, we have the mast we have. But just imagine if your mast was 60 cm taller. This would definitely make for easier hauling of the sail bundle, because it would reduce the angle between the mast and the yard, so that you would be pulling more directly upwards, with less horizontal component to the pull. This means less force required.
Moreover, if any crossover from one side to the other, or even any accidental twist in the halyard, is spread over an extra 60 cm, the lines will not be so tightly pushed together and are much less likely to jam up, or so it seems to me.
Thinner halyards
Is there a partial solution to the friction issue, and even the accidental twist issue, if we use thinner lines? Modern Dyneema rope is very, very strong, so we hardly need 8, 10, or even 12 mm rope to manage the weight of our sail bundles, and if we used thinner rope surely that would mean less friction? Or maybe I don’t understand the physics. Thinner rope might actually mean greater force for each square millimetre of contact between the line and the block and add to the friction? But then there’d be fewer total square millimetres of contact. Anyone know the answer?
But anyway, if I was using a winch this would not matter so much, but as I raise sail by hand I want a nice soft-feeling rope of 8 mm or more, not a thin and potentially slick-feeling Dyneema.
More radical solutions
That leads me to wonder whether there are other solutions that might be more unusual?
If the “problem” arises from having turns of the halyard going back and forth through blocks at the top of the mast, where angles of force and tightness of space can lead to friction and halyard binding, but we definitely need the “leverage” of three- or four-part arrangements, can we change the way in which we get that leverage, without super-expensive winches, hopefully?
What about putting the block and tackle in the stretch between the top of the mast and the deck — running along the mast, in other words — instead of between the yard and the top of the mast? No extra windage; indeed the shelter of the mast might help. But maybe some potential for noise and scrapes as the tackle bangs against the mast. But if any jam was to arise, it would happen at the bottom of the mast where the blocks come together. So much easier to fix. Less tackle up top where it can’t be seen.
But the real problem seems likely to be that while at full sail the block and tackle will be stowed down at the bottom of the mast, a half-reefed sail might find itself leaning against the blocks and lines at some points of sail. Potential for fraying of sailcloth?
What about putting the block and tackle on the deck? That has attractions. A much cleaner line of pull, easy to access, only one line going up top and only a single simple block up there. Moreover, it would work better with a mast that is height-challenged, because the yard could be hauled a bit closer to the top. But it would add to clutter on the deck, and depending on the boat there might not be sufficient length on deck to allow the halyard system to fit.
So despite this “thought experiment”, I think I am back to the traditional arrangement, maybe thinking about in-line blocks and perhaps, in the long term, about a longer mast, and meanwhile being most careful about checking that the blocks are right and the halyard is not twisted each time out.